A literature review: what was already known before this story. Sources are numbered and listed under References.
This literature review examines the historical context and scholarly research surrounding papal visits, religious structures, and social dynamics in Latin America. Prior to recent events, academic studies have focused on the institutional influence of the Catholic Church, religious diversification, and the intersection of religious worldviews with state laws. This review is organised into a historical overview of the papacy and church leadership, followed by thematic evaluations of religious sociology and the legal frameworks governing social policy in the region.
Historical Context of Papal Leadership
Historical documentation establishes the institutional structures of the Catholic Church and the selection processes for its leaders. According to Wikipedia's history of Pope Leo XIV [1], the Pope serves as the head of the Catholic Church and sovereign of Vatican City. Preceding this era, historical records detail the 2013 conclave held on March 12 and March 13, 2013, to elect a successor to Benedict XVI, who had resigned on February 28, 2013 (Wikipedia's history of the 2013 conclave) [6]. Out of 117 eligible cardinal electors, all but two attended that meeting, resulting in the election of Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio on the fifth ballot, who subsequently took the name Francis (Wikipedia's history of the 2013 conclave) [6]. In addition to the papacy itself, the administrative framework includes the office of the papal legate, defined as a personal representative of the Pope to foreign nations, other parts of the Catholic Church, or state and monarchical representatives, who is empowered in matters of Catholic faith and ecclesiastical settlements (Wikipedia's history of the papal legate) [7]. Furthermore, political leadership in Argentina has been shaped by Javier Gerardo Milei, an Argentine politician and economist who has served as president since 2023 and previously served as a member of the Chamber of Deputies from 2021 to 2023 (Wikipedia's history of Javier Milei) [8].
Sociology of Religion in Latin America
Scholarly research into religious practices across Latin America has documented significant shifts in cultural and societal structures. De la Torre and Martín (2016) [9] observed that social scientists have long considered religion to be a structuring feature of culture and local society, noting that early studies privileged the political influences of the Catholic Church regarding the state and society owing to the historical centrality of Catholicism in the region. However, de la Torre and Martín (2016) [9] pointed out that native folk religions received less attention, with scholars undervaluing indigenous and African religiosities, even as religions in Latin America currently experience diversification and reconfiguration due to the growing influence of different Christian denominations. Expanding on this religious landscape, Gooren (2010) [10] examined the pentecostalization of religion and society, defined as the combination of Pentecostal growth, Pentecostal influence on other religions, and Pentecostal impact on the rest of society. Gooren (2010) [10] found that increased competition with other religions, such as the Catholic Charismatic Renewal and mainstream Protestantism, forces these traditions to adopt Pentecostal elements like conversion discourses, speaking in tongues, and faith healing, which gradually spread through mass media, political campaigns, and economic behavior.
Religion, Law, and Social Policy
The intersection of religious worldviews, legal systems, and public policy in the region has been a focal point for institutional analysis. Vaggione (2018) [11] noted that contemporary sexual politics in Latin America present a challenge to rethink the relations between religion and law, particularly as debates on the regulations of sexuality, reproduction, and the family make visible the complex interconnections between religious worldviews and legal systems. According to Vaggione (2018) [11], the secularization of law has remained compatible with an imbrication process in which the legal system translates and conserves Catholic sexual morality into secular regulations. This dynamic involves various stakeholders in conflicts over sexual and reproductive rights mobilizing religion and the law to pursue their respective agendas (Vaggione, 2018) [11]. This institutional framework relates directly to broader societal contexts, including recent reports documenting papal itineraries involving public housing and rehabilitation projects in neighborhoods beset by drug violence, as well as visits to facilities for disabled persons amid existing government policies and social tensions (Reports on Pope Leo XIV's South American tour) [2, 3].
What remains unclear
The available literature and reports do not yet provide comprehensive data on the long-term socio-political outcomes of recent papal visits, nor do they fully measure the direct impact of papal commentary on contemporary government policies in Argentina and Uruguay. While sources document historical structures, religious diversification, and legal frameworks, empirical studies analyzing the direct correlation between papal events, crowd engagement ranging from 40,000 to 60,000 attendees, and legislative changes remain limited. Furthermore, discrepancies persist in how different sociological frameworks evaluate the balance between traditional Catholic influence and emerging Pentecostal demographics within local governance.