A literature review: what was already known before this story. Sources are numbered and listed under References.
This literature review provides an overview of the existing research and background context concerning firearms availability, violence, and policing in Europe, as well as general definitions of mass shootings. Understanding these foundational studies helps contextualize recent violent events without drawing new conclusions or taking sides. The review is organized into historical definitions of mass firearms incidents, systematic analyses of European gun violence and legislation, and criminological research regarding the policing and detection of firearms crime across European jurisdictions.
Definitions of Mass Shootings
Background definitions describe a mass shooting as a crime where one or more attackers use guns to kill or injure multiple individuals in rapid succession, which constitutes a form of mass murder when multiple victims are deceased [6]. Different organizations utilize varying criteria, as there is no widely accepted specific definition for the term [6, 7]. Such incidents generally feature the targeting of victims outside a combat setting and typically exclude gang violence, shootouts, and self-defense [6]. Perpetrators of ongoing attacks are often referred to as active shooters [6]. In the United States, research by Newman and Hartman (2017) [8] examined public mass shootings and public support for gun control, while Webster et al. (2020) [9] analyzed the regulation of firearms design, sale, and carrying on fatal mass shootings using data from the Federal Bureau of Investigation's Supplemental Homicide Reports from 1984 to 2017. These studies collectively establish the foundational terminology used to categorize public firearm violence.
Firearms Violence in Europe
Prior research has investigated the relationship between firearm availability and interpersonal violence. Krüsselmann et al. (2021) [10] conducted a systematic review in PLoS ONE noting that while higher availability of firearms has been connected to higher rates of interpersonal violence, previous studies focused mainly on the United States or used aggregated international data. To address whether aggregated findings apply to continental Europe, Krüsselmann et al. (2021) [10] searched nine databases to compile studies exclusively using European data. Complementing this, Bijleveld (2023) [11] in the European Journal of Criminology highlighted that European criminology faces a lack of sufficient pan-European data, noting that while the European Sourcebook provides synchronized criminal justice system statistics, crime incidence data remain patchy because fewer countries conduct victimization surveys and methodological differences hinder cross-country comparisons [11].
Policing Gun Crime in Europe
The enforcement and regulation of firearms have also been examined from a legislative and operational perspective. Hellenbach et al. (2017) [12], writing in the European Journal of Criminology, observed that despite a shared understanding across the European Union that general public access to firearms should be restricted, detailed legislation concerning ownership, use, and trade varies between member states. To determine how stakeholders perceive the impact of these legislative variations on the policing of gun-enabled crime within and across EU countries, Hellenbach et al. (2017) [12] gathered qualitative data from interviews with police, policy, and decision-makers across 13 European countries. Their analysis identified four main themes, including disparities in legislation that present challenges to the effective detection and policing of gun crime in Europe [12].
What remains unclear
The reviewed literature demonstrates a significant methodological gap regarding pan-European data consistency, as noted by Bijleveld (2023) [11], who points out that victimization surveys and crime incidence data remain patchy and incomparable across European countries. Furthermore, Krüsselmann et al. (2021) [10] observed that earlier research on firearms availability and interpersonal violence focused predominantly on the United States, leaving questions about how continental European findings specifically compare. Additionally, while Hellenbach et al. (2017) [12] identified legislative disparities across 13 European nations through qualitative stakeholder interviews, the literature does not yet fully resolve how these varying national laws directly impact specific local operational responses during active firearm incidents.